Q&A with Nikki Baird, VP of strategy & product, Aptos Retail
Nikki Baird sees a potentially soft holiday season that retailers can heat up with the intelligent use of technology.
Chain Store Age recently spoke with retail expert Nikki Baird, VP of strategy & product, Aptos Retail, about difficulties retailers may encounter during the holiday season and how they can leverage technology, including next-gen artificial intelligence solutions such as agentic AI, to maximize their chances of success in the most critical portion of the retail calendar.
What are retailers getting wrong with their holiday strategies?
If retailers built their promotional plans based off some of the early assessments of consumer spending, like Deloitte or National Retail Federation, they probably came out in late summer or very early fall. Looking at consumer debt load and some of the initial things we're starting to hear from retailers, this may turn out to be a softer holiday season than expected.
[READ MORE: Visa: Inflation-adjusted holiday sales to rise 1.1%]
I feel that overall consumer confidence in the holiday season is much lower now than it was when the first surveys about that were fielded, and that inflation is really starting to crush people. Retailers need to take a second look at their promotional strategy and decide if they have set the right promotional strategy for the times that we're in.
How should retailers apply technology to their holiday strategies?
This season will probably be the inflection point for how much AI is shaping consumer discovery and things like holiday gift lists. How can retailers get the sense for how AI changes the in-store shopper?
It comes down to watching what happens in stores, getting feedback from store associates and positioning technology to help them, because we are in this initial period of where the shopper has access to different information than the store associate. That different information is driven by AI feedback and overviews customers are using on the discovery and planning side.
Meanwhile, the store associate has barely had access to customer information, and now they have less idea of what it was that brought a consumer into the store in the first place. So, making sure that store associates have everything at their disposal to respond to that information gap is going to be important this holiday season.
What can retailers do to better engage customers in-store as well as digitally?
Digitally, there's always opportunity to better connect what's happening online to customers when they come in the store. For example, if you have a chatbot how are customers interacting with it and are there insights that you can filter to your store associates? I also see retailers trying to focus on getting more promotional messages to their store associates to say, for example, this gift item is going to be really hot.
What trends do you see in holiday pricing?
The holiday discounts we have seen so far have been planned. Consumers are shopping for holiday gifts now. The period leading up to Black Friday weekend will show us if demand is softer than retailers expected. Any discounts around Black Friday weekend will be planned. After that will be markdowns. I think with inflation pushing up prices, there will be more unplanned markdown activity earlier in the period between Cyber Monday and Christmas Eve.
What is the proper role of shopping agents – both proprietary and third-party?
I think right now it's still search and discovery, with some evaluation. We still see much more of interactions involving consumers seeking recommendations. But even if one retailer’s shopping bot gives specific recommendations for specific products, the customer may take those as ideas and then go to another retailer to look for them.
Retailers are going to struggle to keep their agents relevant, and the problem is that while that a retailer’s shopper agent might know a lot about things like that retailer's policies, consumers know that they're biased toward that retailer's own selection.
Also, I have not seen a retailer claim that they have increased their sales overall because of the use of shopping agents, proprietary or third-party. They may say shopping agents convert better or have larger basket sizes, but they do not say that their overall sales increase because of the use of these agents, and that continues to concern me that we may just be channel shifting from the retailer's perspective.
