Happy Returns: The typical return fraudster is…
New data from Happy Returns reveals the demographic characteristics most commonly associated with consumers who commit return fraud.
The Returns Happy 2026 study from Happy Returns, a reverse logistics and software company owned by UPS, indicates true return fraud with criminal intent (as opposed to unethical return behavior such as ordering multiple sizes of a product with intent to only keep one item) is most often committed by male consumers (53%) with an average age of 38.9 years (millennials).
[READ MORE: Returns, shrink totaled nearly $800B in 2025]
The typical return fraudster has also placed 29.6 orders in the past year with average order spend of $203 and makes an average 8.1 returns per year. Close to three-in-10 (28%) of all respondents have engaged in true criminal return fraud.
Although the average consumer who commits return fraud is millennial, when asked what types of fraud and unethical return behavior they have engaged in, Gen Z respondents showed much higher rates than the overall respondent base:
- Returned an item with the tag removed – 34% overall/47% Gen Z.
- Returned past the return window (30%/44%).
- Returned a worn item (26%/48%).
- Returned a less expensive item than the one purchased (21%/40%).
- Returned a different item than the one indicated (19%/36%).
- Shipped fewer items back than indicated (19%/36%).
- Edited return label to ship it back to address different than the one indicated by the retailer (19%/37%).
When asked if they were engaging in unethical return behavior more, less or about the same as the previous year 15% of Gen Z respondents said they are doing so more, compared to only 9% of millennials and 4% each of Gen X and baby boomers.
Close to six-in-10 (57%) said they are doing so about the same, compared to 51% of millennials, 46% of Gen X and 37% of baby boomers. Gen Z said they are engaging in less unethical return behavior at the lowest rate (28%), compared to 40% of millennials, 50% of Gen X and 59% of baby boomers.
Retailer trends
The study also looked at the prevalence of different types of return fraud being tracked by retailers. Results included:
- Empty box or box of rocks - 61%.
- Overstated quantity returns - 56%.
- Decoy returns - 56%.
- Price switching - 50%.
- No-proof returns - 46%.
- Label tampering - 45%.
Almost four-in-10 (39%) retail respondents reported a significant increase in box-of-rocks and overstated quantity return fraud in the past year. Retail respondents have generally low confidence in their ability to measure and detect return fraud. Only 2% believe they can do so very effectively, 38% somewhat effectively and 61% somewhat ineffectively (total equals more than 100% due to rounding).
Virtually all retail respondents (94%) are concerned about return fraud. This is 13% increase from 83% in 2025 but roughly flat with 93% in 2024.
Happy Returns, a UPS company, conducted two complementary surveys. The first gathered responses from 2,006 consumers who have returned at least one online purchase in the past 12 months. The second engaged 375 professionals involved in e-commerce for large (annual revenue of $250 million-plus) retailers in the U.S. representing a mix of verticals.
