Skip to main content

What Tenants Notice First: Why execution decides the performance of open-air centers

11/18/2026
Brian Lutz
Brian Lutz, VP, business development, Poag Shopping Centers

Ask a retailer why they renewed at a neighborhood center, and you rarely hear about the concept. 

You hear that the parking lot is well lit, the trash gets picked up and the property manager called back the same day. Ask why they left, and you usually hear the opposite.

Smaller open-air centers succeed or struggle on execution. For retailers, it shows up in the shopping experience and in their occupancy costs. For owners, it shows up in renewals, recoveries and, ultimately, value. It's the same execution seen from two sides of the lease.

The challenge is that these details compound quietly. A center can run "fine" for years while service contracts drift above market, CAM billings drift away from the leases and small maintenance items wait their turn. None of it looks like a crisis. It shows up later, in renewals, recoveries and value.

Going into 2027, owners should hold their managers to a standard their tenants would recognize. Here's the standard I'd use.

Five standards for the manager of an open-air center

1. A manager who shows up. Regular time on site is where good management starts. A manager who walks the property catches a lighting outage or a drainage problem before it reaches a tenant's storefront. Tenants feel the difference immediately; owners see it later, at renewal.

2. Accounting both sides can trust. CAM reconciliations should be completed on schedule, and they should be right. Late or inaccurate reconciliations are one of the fastest ways to strain a landlord–tenant relationship, and they leave recoveries uncollected. For the owner, monthly financials should arrive on time and reconcile cleanly, and the reporting should say what to decide, not just what happened.

3. Discipline in the small line items. Landscaping, lighting, signage, parking lot maintenance and waste removal. Much of that cost passes through to tenants in CAM, so discipline here keeps occupancy costs competitive, and competitive occupancy costs make renewals easier. Contracts should be rebid on a regular cycle and scopes sized to the property. The goal isn't to over-amenitize; it's to put dollars where shoppers and tenants notice them.

4. Management and leasing working as one team. The person who handles a tenant's maintenance call often hears things leasing needs to know: who's struggling, who wants more space, what the merchandising mix is missing. When management and leasing operate in separate lanes, that intelligence is lost, and so are chances to keep a good tenant or fill a gap before it shows.

5. An owner's perspective on capital. Retailers want to be in centers that are being reinvested in. Capital planning should be proactive, not a reaction to the next roof leak. A good manager looks at façade updates, outparcels and repositioning the way an owner would: what will this do for the tenants, and what will it do for value?

Managed the way an owner would manage it

Poag is building a third-party management business because we see a gap in the industry. Owners of smaller open-air centers, from family offices to private investors, need the operating depth of an established manager and the attention of an owner-operator. That combination is hard to find. It's how Poag has always worked, because we've always been the owner first.

We manage third-party centers on the same integrated platform we use for our own: property management, accounting, leasing, development and marketing under one roof. Every assignment starts from a zero-based budget built around that center, and we stay boutique by design so senior people stay close to the property.

Here's what that looked like in our first 90 days managing a neighborhood center in California. Our team met with every tenant in week one. Then:

  • Operating expenses fell 16%, about $157,600 a year, after a competitive rebid of security, landscaping, janitorial and trash contracts.
  • A lease-by-lease CAM audit found more than $136,000 in billing discrepancies, including incorrect pro rata shares, untracked caps and insurance billbacks that didn't match the leases.
  • Longstanding problems were fixed: water intrusion at the anchor, roof leaks across multiple spaces and a sewer odor near HVAC intakes.

At a 7% cap rate, those savings imply roughly $2.25 million of added value. The center's ownership put it simply: Poag approached the property "like an owner, not simply a third-party manager." None of it required a new concept. It required someone paying attention.

Five questions to ask your property manager

1. When were you last on site, and what changed because of it?

2. Are our CAM reconciliations completed on time, and how many did tenants dispute last year?

3. When were our service contracts last bid, and what did we save?

4. Does our monthly report tell us what to decide, or only what happened?

5. When did you last ask our tenants what would make them renew? If the answers take longer than a minute, it's worth a closer look.

Take a closer look

Smaller open-air centers remain among the most resilient assets in retail, as long as they're actively managed, cost-conscious and connected to their trade areas. Their tenants already know which ones are. The opportunity is in the execution.

If you own one of these centers and want an outside view of how it measures up, Poag offers a complimentary asset review covering on-site conditions, operating expenses and reporting. There's no obligation; the goal is a clear picture of where performance is being left behind. Request one here.

I'll be at ICSC New York, Dec. 9–10, and I'd welcome the conversation.

 

Brian Lutz is Vice President of Business Development at Memphis, Tenn.-based Poag Shopping Centers. Poag is a national retail real estate firm specializing in the development, redevelopment, management, leasing and marketing of open-air shopping centers and mixed-use environments.

X
This ad will auto-close in 10 seconds